Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Reeegan's avatar
4dEdited

I'm not so sure, Jamie. I won't go down the rabbit hole of rewriting a post in which I argued against almost every one of these points, but as a vigneron growing wine in Bordeaux, I can't help but see that much of what you're celebrating is really the genius of the classified Médoc, rather than Bordeaux as a whole.

And perhaps that's part of the problem. We keep defining this enormous, geographically diverse region through the success of a relatively small number of famous châteaux, rather than asking what each of these places have to say.

I actually just posted it a few days ago, I suspect we disagree on quite a bit, but I'd be interested in your thoughts:

https://southold.substack.com/p/bordeaux-is-not-a-flavor?r=9jnhv&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web

Marco Nardi's avatar

Thank you for writing this piece. It is needed, as the view from the outside world is of an historical wine regions on the verge of falling to oblivion, which is definitely not the case. I wish Italian wine producers ( there are a few but not many) will start to think about releasing back vintages and retain some of the current stock for future release too. It will give a different understanding to sommelier and consumer about what time can do to wines you though more for casual occasion, but with no real opportunity to deliver memorable experiences.

10 more comments...

Ready for more?