Yesterday I attended a lunch at stylish Piccadilly restaurant Hyde, put on by Saint-Julien third growth Château Lagrange. And this morning I’ll be heading to Lindley Hall to taste through the 2024 vintage in bottle courtesy of the Union des Grands Crus (we get to taste most of the swanky wines, with first growths and the likes of Petrus and Cheval Blanc excepted).
Lagrange are making some excellent wines, and have been for some time. You get the feeling they don’t always get the credit they deserve, because in the past they’ve not chased a style that won too much favour with certain critics. Matthieu Bordes, winemaker here for 20 years now, has gone so far as to say that Parker hated Lagrange.
I think now, the more restrained style of Lagrange is now quite common among top Château in a post-Parker world, and perhaps it will be the norm in the future post-primeur world. As recently as 2022 Lagrange sold 80% en primeur and kept 20% back; this year they will make more turnover selling back vintages, and primeur now makes up 40% of their business. They still sell 100% through La Place. My hot buying tip: 2016 Les Fiefs de Lagrange. An amazing wine, largely underscored by the critics.
So my mind is very Bordeaux focused at the moment, and while the narrative that Bordeaux is a wine region in trouble seems to drive the pen of most writers at the moment, let us pause and consider the genius of this region.
The first is simplicity. Terroir matters in Bordeaux, because you can’t make great wine from poor terroir, and all the top wines are made from exceptional terroirs. But we don’t have Burgundy-level parcellation where each producer makes a dozen wines at least every vintage. Each châteaux makes a Grand Vin and one or two second wines, and that’s it. So you can get to know the wines and follow them over many vintages, without having to become a region expert. Learn the names of half a dozen château that you like the style of, and as a private collector you can have a satisfying experience buying a case from each every now and again, and then following the bottles over time.
The second is scale. These properties are usually quite big. Lagrance has 106 hectares under vine and has the potential to plant 118. And from a business point of view, the Grand Vin is made in large quantities, so the markets can all be well supplied. For most properties, the Grand Vin is their largest production. It means that the secondary market is always selling enough of the wine that the market price is established. This leads to transparency in pricing.
The third is the way the wines are sold, through La Place to the negociants. There may be some criticisms of the en primeur system that are justified, but La Place is a very efficient way of selling. Think of this: without it, every château would have to employ a sales team and work hard in the market, which is a big added expense.
The fourth, and here I’m talking solely of the Médoc, we have an enduring classification system that has proved remarkably durable. The 1855 classification is annoyingly useful, even though you’d expect it to be completely redundant considering it dates from a very different era in Bordeaux pre-phylloxera, pre-modern winemaking technology and from a time when Malbec was the main variety. It was based on the selling prices of wines, and its enduring usefulness may be because the selling priced were dependent largely on terroir, and these haven’t changed much (although if you are a second growth in Pauillac and buy the vineyards of a fourth growth also in Pauillac, they suddenly become second growth). But there’s also the feedback reinforcement mechanism: those higher up in the classification make more money, and as long as they invest it wisely, then make better wine. They can afford to perform at a higher level. And when newcomers with money come in, they want a classed growth, so merely being on a higher rung in the classification will draw in more investment, which will likely raise wine quality.
So this classification has really helped the Médoc, and that fact that it is so old has kept it from legal challenge and any movement to reclassify periodically. Saint-Émilion tried their own classification, but this looks dead in the water after repeated legal challenges and the withdrawal of key properties.
The fifth strength of the region is its reliance on blends. This could be important for the future because it allows adaptation by modifying the blend, and also introducing new varieties without the need for widespread re-education of consumers and changing the very nature of the wine. Longer-cycle grapes and disease-resistant varieties can gradually be introduced without changing the nature of Bordeaux. Sticking with the same varieties is guaranteed to change the nature of the wines because of climate change (and chaos). To keep the style of Bordeaux: concentrated yet fresh, digestible red wines with long ageing potential (and, to a lesser extent, fresh, incisive whites that develop nicely in bottle), things have to change in the vineyard.
Bordeaux does face challenges, but among wine regions worldwide it is not unique in this regard. By introducing the new Claret category of chillable, smashable red wines, it has shown that it can adapt and change where this is needed.
To finish with, the one change that would be really helpful given climate chaos would be a loosening on the restrictions surrounding irrigation. Currently, the official process by which this is permitted takes too long to action, and some of the historically best terroirs, with free-draining gravelly soils, suffer a lot in drought. Lagrange lost 12 000 forty-year-old vines back in 2022 because they couldn’t irrigate. Let everyone install drip irrigation and treat them like adults, trusting them to use it as a viticultural tool for quality rather than assuming they are going to ‘cheat’ and just boost yields.







I'm not so sure, Jamie. I won't go down the rabbit hole of rewriting a post in which I argued against almost every one of these points, but as a vigneron growing wine in Bordeaux, I can't help but see that much of what you're celebrating is really the genius of the classified Médoc, rather than Bordeaux as a whole.
And perhaps that's part of the problem. We keep defining this enormous, geographically diverse region through the success of a relatively small number of famous châteaux, rather than asking what each of these places have to say.
I actually just posted it a few days ago, I suspect we disagree on quite a bit, but I'd be interested in your thoughts:
https://southold.substack.com/p/bordeaux-is-not-a-flavor?r=9jnhv&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web
Thank you for writing this piece. It is needed, as the view from the outside world is of an historical wine regions on the verge of falling to oblivion, which is definitely not the case. I wish Italian wine producers ( there are a few but not many) will start to think about releasing back vintages and retain some of the current stock for future release too. It will give a different understanding to sommelier and consumer about what time can do to wines you though more for casual occasion, but with no real opportunity to deliver memorable experiences.